On the PC, I can chose to land the fish by pressing the A button and I'd say I have a 90% success rate for any speed under, I'm not sure how to explain it, but bouncing wildly from side to side maybe one every half second. I took over for my partner on the xbox last night and I tried to land a fish at least 10 times, meaning 10 different fish and it was even a slow back and forth and out of 40 times, I never once landed one. I tried pressing early, late and right on the mark. NONE landed. Now I see why she never ever even tries. She just brings the fish into the circle and waits for the auto land. This has to be a bug.