Xbox Broken Achievements / Trophies

It's similar to me, I have or can currently except in TSW 2 in every game still reach the 100% Achievements and have there also with many.

My profile is now virtually "destroyed" because the 100% are never again possible and that in the game where I have invested not only the most money but also time.

 

Nope I'm not giving them that out by even entertaining the idea that they can't fix it. They could, if they actually wanted to. But they don't, they've made the conscious decision to show they can't be trusted in anything they say no matter how many times they say it.

 

Also the fact that DTG JD is now suddenly so silent, is simply an insolence of DTG

 

Can I ask with the new game coming out later today for early access once the full game gets released and we get the older DLC has anyone tried the achievements / trophies that’s been broken for a while to see if they are gonna work fine or are we gonna have the same issue as TSW 2 and TSW 3

 

Nobody tests achievements at DTG. If they did, we would not have 99% completion in TSW3, for achievements that worked fine in TSW2.
In my case, I have CL31: Cemented Skillset and HBK: From City to Coast locked in TSW3, after unlocking them in TSW2.

 

Above all, someone from DTG should comment on this ...

 

The trophies on TSW4 for PS5 are mislabelled, duplicated, or don't make sense. Not all of them, but already it's a mess.

 

Yeah, they really really are.

There is a bronze and silver trophy for getting the Flying Scotman to 100mph but only the silver one unlocks for that.

I'm assuming the other one to drive 100mph in the A3 but I'm not sure. I'm going to try tonight.

How did this pass Sony certification on the trophies alone.

 

The bronze one is for finishing a scenario and not for reaching 100mph

 

I too have lost all my tasks!! and therefore, all the bonuses linked to the completion of these tasks!! I have more than ten "bonuses" unlocked in TSW4, which are lost in TSW4!! worse, all the tasks have to be started again!!!

further proof that DTG releases games to make money, but not for real development! worse... other bugs already present have not been corrected!

Dovetail Game, this is the last time you see my money! player since TSW preview on Xbox, and after more than 2000 euros spent at home, the release of TSW4 is a big joke!!! on XSX, it crashes constantly... and when the game can be launched, it is ultra buggy! you take your buyers/players for s****!

 

Thanks for your frustration, what has it to do with this threads topic?

 

Yes, this is primarily about the promised but not fixed Achievements from TSW2.

Anyone who now starts TSW 4 and thinks the Achievements would run there is a bit "blue eyed".

Cement Circle and a broken promise in TSW 2020 what we could then claim yet
TSW 2 the same
TSW 3 also
... TSW 4 will be just such a fight

 

Yes looks like some of the achievements got copied over with the same inaccurate conditions as TSW3.

• Tees Valley Line - complete all scenarios only unlocks on Tubeliner Diversion because it's for a single scenario only
• Diesel Legends - Class 101 tutorial only unlocks when you finish a 465 scenario on Southeastern
• Clinchfield - complete all scenarios only unlocks by completing all scenarios on Cane Creek
• The Class 31 and HBK still has the unobtainable achievements

 

I'm sure we are all shocked by the neverending incompetence.

Honestly, anyone concerned about these things who spends any money on TS4 kinda deserves what they get. It was already proven many times over before TS4 ever released that they can't be trusted to release a functioning game, let alone one where the achievements work. Anybody continuing to give them money is telling them these issues are all acceptable.

Even Blizzard manages Diablo 4 better than Dovetail manages the Train Sim series.

 

glad i threw the series to the side and skipped 4 abfter they lied about fixing 2 and then being up front about not fixing 3. it's crazy the amount of games i can play when not re-earning the same copied over achievements for nearly half a decade.

 

So Cemented Skillset and From City to Coast have already been fixed for TSW4. Any word on a fix for TSW3?

 

no they havent

 

Not sure what you are denying here.
I was able to unlock both these achievements in TSW4.
There's no word on TSW3 fixes, for these achievements or any outstanding issues, promised or otherwise.

 

Maybe the most unsettling thing is, DTG didn't even announce the fixes. That tells me the developers and customer service representatives aren't even communicating with each other let alone us.

 

The fixes were announced for TSW 2 and TSW 3 over a year ago.

On the one hand by dtg_jd JD earlier in this forum post, the TSW 2 fixes were also on several route maps and were discussed in the route maps stream.

DTG is simply not sticking to the standard here and also not sticking to official promises to make improvements to defects in DLCs that have existed since the beginning.

 

They might have unlocked for you, but for me and others it’s not unlocking

 

I disagree that they are not sticking to the standard. The standard is for them to not care about achievements and to only focus on rereleasing the same content with the same bugs in a shinier package for more money. They are great at sticking to their standards.

 

Anyone unlock NYT: Disco Fries yet? It’s on trophy group 23. Complete NYE in NYC scenario in New York Trenton. I’m About half way into the service and get caught a red light.
I’m on TSW4 PS5.

 

Apparently using a gif that through pure comedy (That ‘70s Show) says BURN is not allowed. (Do I need to explain that current use of the word burn means: an intense non-physical sting, as left by shame or an effective insult)
I still support your statement.

 

That's not entirely true. There are three trophies, two of which are for achieving the same goal. reach 100mph in the Flying Scotsman.

Difference is that one is Bronze, the other Silver. The Silver one has a typo in the description too, and the Bronze one is broken, which won't unlock.

FSCT: Centenary - Reach 100 mph in the Flying Scotsman
FSCT: Making History - Complete scenario A on Flying Scotsman
FSCT: Record Breaker! - Reach 100 mph in Flying Scotsman

A lot of these are as if they were written by an illiterate.

 

So will we ever see a fix for LPC Fixing a Hole TSW2 PS4 (NPI)? Or is TSW 2 officially dead for DTG?

 

I doubt it. And fixes for the 143 for 143KM could have been fixed but they did not bother. At the end of the day it will simply turn people away for TSW and they need the money

 

Depends how you define "official". Internally, I'd bet good money that they are officially done providing this game anything remotely close to support. Externally, they'll just stay silent at best and openly lie that they're going to fix it at worst.

 

Well, I haven't started TSW 3 or TSW 4, I can only agree with you and I won't be buying anything from Dovetail again ...

 

The funny thing is they had 2 trophies for 143km for the 143 on RSN route and Dresden route. I have wondered did anyone notice this ?

Both TSW3 and 4 have broken trophies so it continues the ones broken worked in TSW2 I believe and lets not forget mistakes in trophy names like on TSW4 the PS plat is complete all trophies in TSW3! and various other mistakes. I think the people at the top demand content release before its ready so we see the bugs, and they don't have time to fix them properly as they are then forced onto the next piece of content. I fear the lack of QA and fixing problems with end the TSW franchise because more and more people are abandoning the game mostly people at the moment who buy all the content

 

The drive 143km trophy In TSW2, I wonder to if anyone noticed that it's done twice, once is RSN and once in Dresden. The trophy looks like it will never be fixed.

Based on users experience it looks like more and more problems with the trophies/achievements persists from TSW2-TSW3-TSW4.

Wouldn't call myself a hardcore player, don't own all the DLC for example but do have a fair bit. I really enjoyed going for the trophies in TSW2. When you can see that these problems will carry on existing Ive given up trying to get the trophies. Put quite a few hours in TSW2, less so I'm TSW3 and I wouldn't buy TSW4 if it was a fiver, the game looks awful and for console players ps5 people still saying external camera doesn't work?

I get that the product is somewhat niche but I always thought 25 quid for one DLC was mad let alone 30 quid for content which you can assume will have problems which based on track record probably won't all be fixed. I only ever bought on sale.

 

DTG Jamie DTG JD is there some news about the patch for TSW2 for the unobtainable achievement for the BR 143 or ?
i mean that is a long time for such a little problem , just let it auto pop or just change the requierements

 

just give up on it they do not fix achievements for previous TSW versions
after releasing a new TSW
i am on steam
i have TSW 2 and need 1 achievement same for TSW 3 also 1 achievement

 

RRO trophies are broken on this route for the PS5 still. All scenarios and training modules don’t unlock for me.
I thought they had been fixed as now they show 0.1% have unlocked these trophies, maybe devs testing them still?

 

Will these "promised" (read we aren't ever going to deliver) updates going to fix the broken achievements in 3? Or are they going to be totally abandoned like 2 has been?

 

I got this Trophy...the patch work very nice

https://forums.dovetailgames.com/threads/tsw4-unattainable-trophies.77534/

 

Did you get the trophy on your main profile or did you create a new profile?
I couldn’t get this trophy to unlock on my main profile, that has all scenarios and training modules completed.

 

For top of the class new profile...
If you have completed yet all scenarios try with new profile....
But when you have finish one scenarios come back in main menu....and return in scenarios...Always....never to continue of menu scenerios complete

 

Okay so I got the tutorial trophy to unlock on a new profile.
So just to confirm, if I have completed all scenarios on my main profile than I won’t be able to get the trophy for all scenarios completed. Instead I I will have to start again on a new profile and complete them all?

 

that's right...if you've already completed all the scenarios you have to do them all again with a new profile to get it

 

so basicly the broken achievements / trophies will never be fixed. will this be the case with broken trophies / achievements in TSW3 and 4 as well? While I dont expect every bug to be fixed I at least expect trophies / achievements to be fixed

 

That is great news!! Please don't forget about the other broken achievement in TSW3, namely SMH: Old Hat (Complete all training modules for Sherman Hill).

If you miraculously decided to look at TSW2, the 2 broken achievement are:
All consoles - DRA: Dresden Commuter (Operate BR143 for 143km)
PS4/XBOX One - LPC: Fixing a Hole (complete all route tasks on Spirit of Steam) - a coal pile is missing at Crewe Yard North

 

The MSB 100 services trophy and the sherman hill all tutorials are the only 2 TSW3 PS5 trophies I need.

As for the TSW2 Xbox fixing a hole at least if you upgrade to series consoles you can unlock that achievement.

Personally I am glad you have responded. But what DTG needs to do for the future is to make sure all the trophies / achievements can be unlocked before a new TSW game is released. In fairness to DTG you cant support 4 or more versions of TSW so they need to have a cut off point. I think you need to make sure you take care when to implement trophies / achivement's to make sure they work we have had some that work in TSW2 that then did not work in 3. At least with the scaled back trophies / achievements in TSW3 and 4 it should make it easier to fix or should I say less to bug test

 

So for me, TSW 2 is the last Train Sim. It ruined my profile and I spent a lot of money on it, which in the end ruined my hobby.

And for the record: You lied to us, you said you were fixing it for TSW 2, in live streams and your own roadmap.
Then just saying we won't support TSW 2 anymore is not an answer, it just shows that you took us for fools.

 

What MSB achievement is broken? Is this not the XBOX section of the forum? The ONLY two broken achievements for TSW3 on XBOX are CL31: Cemented Skillset and HBK: From City to Coast.


BOTH of which were inherently broken for TSW4 on release, but were already fixed. So what is to test? Roll out the same fix for TSW3.

 

Believe the MSB one in for 100 services and Sherman hill all training modules not unlocking on tsw3 is or playstation users ( not Xbox/steam achievements) so probably is console related issue
View attachment 150640

 

Thanks for nothing !!! just empty promises where made , thanks for destroying my 100% on my Profil